Article 4 · Summer 2025

A New Era of Scientific Discourse: Transparent, AI-Augmented Peer Review for Rapid and Unbiased Scholarly Publishing

Richard Murdoch Montgomery

Abstract

Traditional academic peer review is plagued by systemic issues including significant delays, reviewer bias, and prohibitive costs. This paper introduces a novel operational model for scholarly publishing that leverages multiple large language models to conduct rapid, transparent, and unbiased peer review. We describe the architecture of our AI-augmented system, which requires consensus from at least two out of three different AI models, with all reviews published alongside manuscripts. Initial data from the first year demonstrates significant reduction in time-to-publication and successful evaluation of highly interdisciplinary research.

The article

Read the full article (PDF)

The reviews

Published in full, as the Society’s method requires. How review works.

How to cite

Montgomery, R. M. (2025). A New Era of Scientific Discourse: Transparent, AI-Augmented Peer Review for Rapid and Unbiased Scholarly Publishing. Scottish Science Society, 1(1). ISSN 2755-6360.